You've been asking me for a dupe for the ABH in lipstick in Rio for the longest time and I finally found one. It's the MUA luxe velvet lip lacquer in the shade criminal.
The formula is very similar to the ABH lipstick, pigmented, waterproof, and long lasting. It doesn't apply patchily and dries matte instantly. However, both the lipsticks are very drying and it works best when you apply a good layer of lip balm before wearing either of them.
You can buy it here: http://amzn.to/2c5PAuP